Can you give an example of a situation where you had to adjust estimates and project budgets as designs changed?
Estimator Interview Questions
Sample answer to the question
In my previous role as an Estimator, I was involved in a construction project where the designs changed midway through the project. Initially, we had estimated the cost of materials and labor based on the original designs. However, when the changes were made, I had to adjust the estimates and project budgets accordingly. I worked closely with the project team, including engineers, architects, and contractors, to understand the revised designs and analyze the impact on the costs. I revised the quantities and prices of the materials and recalculated the labor hours needed for the new requirements. I also consulted with suppliers and subcontractors to negotiate new prices and availability of materials. By adjusting the estimates and project budgets, we were able to effectively manage the changes without exceeding the allocated budget.
A more solid answer
In a recent construction project I worked on as an Estimator, we encountered design changes that required adjustments to the estimates and project budgets. Initially, I had estimated the costs based on the original designs, considering factors like materials, labor, and equipment. However, when the designs changed, I immediately recognized the need for revision. I collaborated with the project team and met with engineers, architects, and contractors to understand the new requirements. I carefully analyzed the impact of the changes on the costs and adjusted the estimates accordingly. This involved recalculating quantities, prices, and labor hours, as well as considering any additional materials or equipment needed. I also leveraged my negotiation skills to engage with suppliers and subcontractors, ensuring that we obtained the best pricing and availability for the revised requirements. By effectively adjusting the estimates and project budgets, we successfully accommodated the design changes without exceeding the allocated budget.
Why this is a more solid answer:
The solid answer provides a more detailed example of the candidate's experience in adjusting estimates and project budgets. It includes specific skills like numerical accuracy and analytical thinking, as well as highlighting their collaboration with the project team and negotiation skills. However, it can still be improved by mentioning the use of estimating software and providing more specific details about the adjustments made.
An exceptional answer
I would like to share a situation from my previous role as an Estimator where I had to navigate complex design changes and effectively manage the estimates and project budgets. The project involved the construction of a commercial building, and during the mid-phase, the architecture team made significant alterations to the design to enhance the building's functionality and aesthetics. As an experienced Estimator, I immediately recognized the implications of these changes on the overall project cost. I initiated a series of meetings with the project team, including architects, engineers, and contractors, to gain a comprehensive understanding of the revised plans and the impact on different aspects like materials, labor, and equipment. I then utilized advanced estimating software like Timberline to accurately calculate the revised quantities, prices, and labor hours required. The software also helped me identify any overlaps or inefficiencies in the revised design and propose cost-saving alternatives without compromising quality. Additionally, I proactively engaged with suppliers and subcontractors to renegotiate contracts, ensuring competitive pricing and availability of the required materials. By closely monitoring the adjustments in estimates and project budgets, we successfully managed the entire process and ensured that the project was completed within the allocated budget and timeline, exceeding the client's expectations.
Why this is an exceptional answer:
The exceptional answer provides a compelling and detailed example of the candidate's experience in handling complex design changes and managing estimates and project budgets. It demonstrates their ability to navigate challenging situations, utilize advanced estimating software, and leverage negotiation skills to achieve cost savings. The answer also highlights their proactive approach and focus on exceeding client expectations. Overall, the candidate's exceptional answer showcases their expertise and provides a comprehensive understanding of the skills required for the role.
How to prepare for this question
- Familiarize yourself with estimating software like Timberline, ProEst, or similar.
- Ensure you have a strong understanding of construction practices and labor costs.
- Be prepared to discuss your experience in reading and interpreting blueprints and technical documents.
- Highlight your analytical thinking and numerical accuracy skills during the interview.
- Share examples of situations where you collaborated with cross-functional teams and successfully managed project budgets.
What interviewers are evaluating
- Cost estimating
- Project management
Related Interview Questions
More questions for Estimator interviews