/Estimator/ Interview Questions
INTERMEDIATE LEVEL

Tell us about a time when you identified errors or inconsistencies in project plans or specifications. How did you address the issue?

Estimator Interview Questions
Tell us about a time when you identified errors or inconsistencies in project plans or specifications. How did you address the issue?

Sample answer to the question

There was one time when I was working on a construction project and noticed some errors in the project plans. Specifically, there were inconsistencies between the specifications and the blueprints. I immediately brought this to the attention of my project team and we held a meeting to discuss the issue. We reviewed the plans and specifications together and identified the errors. We then contacted the architect and the client to inform them about the discrepancies and propose solutions. After thorough discussions and negotiations, we were able to resolve the inconsistencies and update the project plans accordingly. This experience taught me the importance of careful review and attention to detail, as well as effective communication with stakeholders.

A more solid answer

In my previous role as an estimator for a construction company, I encountered a situation where I identified errors and inconsistencies in a project's plans and specifications. During the review process, I noticed that the estimated quantities of certain materials were not aligned with the project's scope and size. This raised concerns about the accuracy of the cost estimate and the overall feasibility of the project. To address the issue, I immediately consulted with the project team, including architects, engineers, and project managers. Together, we conducted a thorough analysis of the plans and specifications, comparing them with industry standards and best practices. This allowed us to identify the specific errors and inconsistencies that needed to be addressed. We then organized a meeting with the client to discuss our findings and propose solutions. Through effective communication and negotiation, we were able to reach a consensus on the necessary adjustments to the project plans. This required coordinating with various stakeholders, including suppliers and subcontractors, to update the cost estimate and ensure its accuracy. By leveraging my analytical thinking, knowledge of construction practices, and attention to detail, I played a crucial role in resolving the issues and ensuring the project's success.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer provides more specific details about the situation and the candidate's actions in addressing the issue. It demonstrates their analytical thinking, knowledge of construction practices, attention to detail, and communication skills. However, it could be further improved by including more examples of how the candidate utilized their skills and knowledge to resolve the inconsistencies.

An exceptional answer

As an experienced estimator in the construction industry, I have encountered numerous instances where errors or inconsistencies were identified in project plans or specifications. One notable example was during a high-profile commercial construction project. During the initial review of the plans and specifications, I discovered significant discrepancies between the architectural drawings and the mechanical specifications. These inconsistencies threatened the project's timeline and budget. To address this issue, I immediately reached out to the project team, including architects, engineers, subcontractors, and suppliers, to form a cross-functional task force. We conducted a comprehensive analysis of the plans, focusing on the conflicting areas, and gathered additional information from external sources. Leveraging my expertise in reading blueprints and technical documents, I pinpointed the errors and collaborated with the architects to develop revised drawings that aligned with the mechanical specifications. Simultaneously, I communicated with the subcontractors and suppliers to ensure they understood the modifications and adjust their cost estimates accordingly. This collaborative effort greatly minimized the impact on the project's progress and budget. Moreover, I implemented preventive measures, such as establishing a thorough review process, to prevent similar issues from occurring in future projects. This experience showcased my strong analytical thinking, attention to detail, and ability to effectively collaborate with stakeholders in a time-sensitive and high-pressure environment.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer demonstrates the candidate's extensive experience in encountering errors or inconsistencies in project plans and specifications. It provides a detailed and comprehensive example of how the candidate successfully addressed such an issue in a high-profile commercial construction project. The answer highlights their ability to lead a cross-functional task force, utilize their expertise in reading blueprints and technical documents, collaborate effectively with stakeholders, and implement preventive measures. Additionally, it emphasizes their analytical thinking, attention to detail, and ability to perform under high-pressure situations. The answer showcases the candidate's strong qualifications and suitability for the Estimator role in the construction industry.

How to prepare for this question

  • Familiarize yourself with industry standard estimating software, such as Timberline or ProEst, to improve your efficiency in analyzing project plans and specifications.
  • Stay updated on construction practices and labor costs by regularly researching and reading industry publications and attending relevant seminars or workshops.
  • Develop strong analytical and critical thinking skills by practicing solving complex problems related to estimating costs and analyzing project plans.
  • Improve your communication and negotiation skills by participating in role-playing exercises or enrolling in relevant courses or workshops.
  • Focus on attention to detail by practicing reviewing project plans and specifications thoroughly, identifying potential errors or inconsistencies.

What interviewers are evaluating

  • Analytical thinking
  • Communication
  • Attention to detail
  • Knowledge of construction practices and labor costs

Related Interview Questions

More questions for Estimator interviews