Can you provide an example of a time when you had to deal with unexpected changes or challenges during the estimation process?
Estimator Interview Questions
Sample answer to the question
Yes, I can provide an example of a time when I had to deal with unexpected changes during the estimation process. It was during a construction project I was working on. We were estimating the cost of materials and labor for building a new office building. However, halfway through the estimation process, we received new specifications from the client that required significant changes to the design and scope of work. This meant that our initial estimates were no longer valid. I had to quickly adapt to the changes and re-evaluate the costs based on the new specifications. I collaborated with the project team, engineers, and suppliers to gather updated information and make accurate calculations. It was a challenging situation, but we managed to adjust the estimates and deliver a revised proposal to the client within the deadline.
A more solid answer
Certainly! Let me share a specific example of when unexpected changes occurred during the estimation process. I was working on a construction project to build a new hospital wing. During the estimation phase, we encountered a challenge when the client decided to make significant changes to the design, including adding an additional floor and increasing the square footage. This required us to re-evaluate the cost estimates to account for the changes in materials, labor, and overall project scope. To handle this situation, I immediately convened a meeting with the project team, architects, and subcontractors to discuss the impact of the changes and gather their insights. We analyzed the revised plans and blueprints to determine the new quantities and costs. I proactively reached out to suppliers and obtained updated pricing for the additional materials. By collaborating closely with all stakeholders and utilizing my analytical skills, we were able to adjust the estimates accordingly and provide the client with an updated and accurate proposal within the agreed-upon timeline. This experience taught me the importance of adaptability, communication, and collaboration in navigating unexpected changes during the estimation process.
Why this is a more solid answer:
This is a solid answer as it provides a specific example of a construction project where unexpected changes occurred during the estimation process. The candidate demonstrates their ability to adapt to the changes, collaborate with the project team and stakeholders, utilize their analytical skills, and deliver accurate estimates within a deadline. However, it could be improved by including more details on the specific challenges faced and the candidate's problem-solving approach in dealing with those challenges.
An exceptional answer
Absolutely! Let me walk you through a challenging experience I had with unexpected changes during the estimation process. I was leading the estimation for a high-rise residential building project. Everything seemed to be going smoothly until the client requested a complete redesign of the building facade, which entailed changing the materials, finishes, and even the structural support system. This unexpected change had a significant impact on the cost estimation process. To address this challenge, I immediately initiated a thorough review of the revised architectural and engineering plans. I conducted detailed research on alternative materials and finishes to understand their availability, cost implications, and impact on the overall project timeline. I engaged in extensive collaboration with the project team, including architects, engineers, subcontractors, and suppliers, to gather their expertise and insights. This allowed us to make informed decisions on the most cost-effective and efficient options while ensuring compliance with safety and quality standards. I also proactively negotiated with suppliers and subcontractors to obtain competitive pricing for the new materials and incorporated them into our revised cost estimates. Additionally, I utilized advanced estimating software to perform accurate calculations, taking into account the revised specifications. Through effective project management and communication, we were able to adjust the estimates, revise the project budget, and present the updated proposal to the client within the agreed-upon timeline. This experience not only honed my adaptability and problem-solving skills but also deepened my understanding of construction practices, cost management, and the importance of continuous collaboration.
Why this is an exceptional answer:
This is an exceptional answer as it provides a detailed and comprehensive example of a construction project where unexpected changes occurred during the estimation process. The candidate showcases their ability to handle complex challenges, communicate effectively with various stakeholders, conduct thorough research, negotiate with suppliers, and utilize advanced estimating software. The answer also highlights the candidate's project management skills and their understanding of construction practices and cost management. Overall, it demonstrates a high level of expertise and competency in dealing with unexpected changes during the estimation process.
How to prepare for this question
- Familiarize yourself with industry standard estimating software like Timberline or ProEst, as proficiency in this software is required for the role.
- Brush up on your analytical thinking and problem-solving skills, as you will need to analyze plans and specifications, calculate quantities and costs, and adjust estimates based on unexpected changes.
- Review your experience with reading blueprints and technical documents, as this knowledge is essential for accurately interpreting architectural and engineering plans.
- Reflect on past projects or experiences where you had to deal with unexpected changes or challenges during the estimation process. Think about the specific steps you took to overcome those challenges and ensure accurate estimations.
- Practice communicating and collaborating with cross-functional teams, as the role of an estimator often involves working closely with engineers, architects, clients, and vendors.
What interviewers are evaluating
- Adaptability
- Analytical Thinking
- Collaboration
- Problem Solving
Related Interview Questions
More questions for Estimator interviews