Tell us about a time when you had to make a difficult ethical decision in your legal practice.
General Counsel Interview Questions
Sample answer to the question
In my previous legal practice, I encountered a difficult ethical decision when I was representing a client in a labor dispute case. The client wanted me to use unethical tactics to discredit the opposing party and gain an advantage in the case. However, I firmly believe in conducting myself with integrity and adhering to the principles of professional ethics. I explained to the client that such tactics were not only unethical but also could backfire and harm our case in the long run. I advised a more ethical approach, focusing on presenting strong evidence and making sound legal arguments. Eventually, the client understood and agreed to pursue the case with an ethical strategy. This experience taught me the importance of standing firm in upholding ethical standards, even in challenging situations.
A more solid answer
One of the most challenging ethical decisions I faced in my legal practice involved a client who wanted me to use confidential information obtained through unethical methods in a litigation case. Although the client insisted that it would give us an advantage, I understood the importance of maintaining the principles of confidentiality and professional ethics. I thoroughly explained the potential legal implications and risks of using such information, which could have serious consequences for our reputation and the credibility of our case. I made it clear that I could not compromise my integrity and advised the client to pursue the case through legitimate means. Ultimately, the client understood the significance of adhering to ethical standards and agreed to follow the appropriate legal procedures. This experience reinforced my commitment to upholding professional ethics and confidentiality, even in challenging situations.
Why this is a more solid answer:
The solid answer expands on the basic answer by providing a specific example of the ethical decision and the principles of confidentiality and professional ethics. It includes a detailed explanation of the potential consequences and risks associated with using unethical methods and emphasizes the candidate's commitment to upholding professional ethics.
An exceptional answer
During my legal practice, there was a challenging ethical decision I had to make regarding the disclosure of confidential client information. I was representing a corporate client in a complex business transaction, and a major issue arose where the client's interests conflicted with a third-party's rights. The client strongly urged me to use privileged information to gain an advantage in the negotiation process. However, I knew that disclosing confidential client information would not only violate legal and ethical obligations but also potentially result in serious legal consequences. I immediately informed the client about the importance of maintaining the principles of confidentiality and professional ethics. I explained the potential liability not only to the client but also to myself as a legal practitioner. I presented the client with alternative legal strategies that adhere to ethical standards while still protecting their interests. After a thorough discussion, the client understood the gravity of the situation and agreed to pursue an ethical approach. This experience reinforced my conviction to prioritize professional ethics and uphold the principles of confidentiality, even in challenging business transactions.
Why this is an exceptional answer:
The exceptional answer enhances the solid answer by providing more specific details and context of the ethical decision. It emphasizes the potential legal consequences of violating confidentiality, demonstrates the candidate's ability to present alternative ethical strategies, and highlights their commitment to upholding professional ethics in complex business transactions.
How to prepare for this question
- Reflect on past experiences where you faced difficult ethical decisions and consider how you handled them.
- Familiarize yourself with legal codes of conduct and professional ethics guidelines to understand the expected standards.
- Think about potential scenarios related to the job responsibilities and how you would approach them from an ethical standpoint.
- Practice articulating your decision-making process in ethical dilemmas, highlighting the importance of integrity and adherence to ethical principles.
- Be prepared to discuss the long-term impact of your ethical decisions and how they can contribute to a positive work environment.
What interviewers are evaluating
- Strong principles of confidentiality and professional ethics
Related Interview Questions
More questions for General Counsel interviews