Tell us about a time when you received constructive criticism on your work. How did you handle it?

Sample answer to the question

I remember a time when I received constructive criticism on a report I had prepared during an audit. My supervisor pointed out that my analysis was not thorough enough and that I had missed some key details. At first, I felt a bit deflated, but then I realized that their feedback was an opportunity for growth. I took their advice to heart and immediately went back to the report to review my work. I analyzed the data more carefully, double-checked my calculations, and made sure to include all relevant information. I also sought guidance from my supervisor on how to improve my analysis. In the end, I was able to revise the report to meet the expectations and received positive feedback on the improved quality of my work.

A more solid answer

During an audit assignment, I received constructive criticism on my work from a senior auditor. They pointed out that I had missed an important financial detail in my analysis, which affected the accuracy of our findings. Initially, I felt disappointed, but I quickly realized the value of their feedback. I took immediate action by reviewing my work, conducting additional research, and seeking clarification from the senior auditor. I then made the necessary updates to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the analysis. To prevent similar mistakes in the future, I implemented a checklist to guide my review process and incorporated regular peer reviews. This experience taught me the importance of attention to detail and strengthened my commitment to continuous improvement.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer expands upon the basic answer by providing more specific details about the situation, the feedback received, and the candidate's actions. It also highlights the candidate's ability to take initiative, learn from mistakes, and implement improvements. However, it could still provide more examples of how the candidate demonstrated the evaluation areas mentioned in the job description, such as analytical and critical thinking.

An exceptional answer

During an audit engagement, I received valuable constructive criticism from a senior auditor regarding my approach to analyzing financial data. They pointed out that I was relying too heavily on automated tools and not leveraging my analytical skills effectively. This feedback resonated with me, as I realized the importance of applying critical thinking in addition to utilizing technology. To address this feedback, I immediately sought additional training on advanced data analysis techniques, allowing me to perform more complex analyses manually. I also implemented a proactive approach to discuss potential analytical strategies with my supervisor before starting a project. This adjustment significantly improved the depth and accuracy of my analysis and ultimately led to more meaningful insights for our clients. Embracing this feedback enhanced my analytical and critical thinking abilities, ensuring my work contributes to the team's success.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer goes beyond the solid answer by providing a more comprehensive and detailed response. It includes specific examples of how the candidate addressed the feedback, sought additional training, and improved their analytical approach. It also emphasizes the impact of their actions on the team's success and their commitment to continuous improvement. This answer demonstrates the candidate's exceptional analytical and critical thinking abilities and eagerness to learn and adapt in a fast-paced environment.

How to prepare for this question

Reflect on past experiences where you have received constructive criticism on your work and think about how you handled it.
Consider the skills and evaluation areas mentioned in the job description and prepare examples that highlight your abilities in those areas.
Practice describing the situation, the feedback received, your immediate actions, and the long-term improvements you implemented.
Research and familiarize yourself with various auditing techniques and industry standards to showcase your eagerness to learn.
Think about how you can demonstrate your organizational and multitasking abilities in your response.

What interviewers are evaluating

Analytical and critical thinking
Excellent verbal and written communication
Organizational and multitasking abilities
Eagerness to learn and adapt in a fast-paced environment