/Appraiser/ Interview Questions
INTERMEDIATE LEVEL

Tell me about a time when you identified an error or discrepancy in an appraisal report. How did you handle it?

Appraiser Interview Questions
Tell me about a time when you identified an error or discrepancy in an appraisal report. How did you handle it?

Sample answer to the question

During my time as an appraiser, I encountered a situation where I identified an error in an appraisal report. I noticed that the report failed to include crucial information about the property's unique features, which could significantly impact its value. To handle this, I immediately brought it to the attention of my supervisor and provided them with the necessary details. We discussed the issue, and my supervisor appreciated my attention to detail. To rectify the error, we decided to revise the report by including the missing information and submitting it to the client. This experience taught me the importance of thoroughness in appraisal reports and the need for effective communication within the team.

A more solid answer

During my tenure as an appraiser, I encountered a significant error in an appraisal report. While reviewing the report, I noticed that the property's unique features, such as a newly renovated kitchen and updated flooring, were not included in the description or photographs. These features could significantly impact the property's value. I immediately brought this discrepancy to the attention of my supervisor, providing them with detailed information about the missing elements. We scheduled a meeting to discuss the issue further and determine the best course of action. My supervisor recognized the importance of rectifying the error and appreciated my attention to detail in identifying it. Together, we decided to revise the report by including accurate descriptions, photographs, and diagrams that highlighted the property's unique features. I took the lead in updating the report, working diligently to ensure accuracy and precision. Once the revisions were complete, we submitted the revised report to the client, along with a sincere apology for the oversight. This experience reinforced the significance of thoroughness in appraisal reports and the value of effective communication within the team. It also showcased my ability to work independently and take ownership of rectifying errors in a timely manner.

Why this is a more solid answer:

The solid answer expands on the basic answer by providing specific details about the error in the appraisal report (missing property's unique features) and its potential impact on the valuation. It also adds information about the candidate's role in updating the report and their attention to detail. However, it can still be improved by further emphasizing the candidate's ability to work independently and their effective communication skills.

An exceptional answer

As an experienced appraiser, I encountered a critical error in an appraisal report that required immediate attention. While scrutinizing the report, I discovered that not only were the property's unique features omitted, but there were also inaccuracies in the square footage calculations. This meant that the valuation could be significantly affected. Recognizing the gravity of the situation, I quickly initiated a dialogue with the team, including the appraiser who prepared the report and our supervisor. By approaching the situation with empathy and professionalism, I ensured that the appraiser did not feel attacked or defensive. Instead, we collaboratively reviewed the primary data sources, such as the property inspection and comparable sales, to rectify the errors accurately. Working independently, without compromising teamwork, I revised the report by incorporating the missing information about the unique features and conducting accurate square footage calculations. To ensure the highest level of accuracy, I also cross-checked my revisions with industry-specific software. As a final step, I sought approval from my supervisor and involved the appraiser in a peer review process. This approach allowed us to maintain trust and ownership while guaranteeing quality assurance. Our revised report was submitted to the client with a sincere apology for the initial oversight, accompanied by our assurance of a prompt resolution. This experience highlighted my exceptional attention to detail, effective communication, independent problem-solving skills, and commitment to maintaining ethical and professional standards.

Why this is an exceptional answer:

The exceptional answer elevates the response by providing additional specific details about the errors in the appraisal report (missing unique features and square footage inaccuracies) and the candidate's proactive approach in resolving them. It also emphasizes the candidate's ability to work independently and problem-solve while maintaining effective communication with the team. Furthermore, the answer demonstrates the candidate's commitment to ethical and professional standards. This comprehensive response addresses all the evaluation areas and highlights the candidate's suitability for the Appraiser position.

How to prepare for this question

  • Familiarize yourself with different appraisal methodologies and regulations to understand industry standards and compliance requirements.
  • Develop strong analytical and research skills to ensure accurate valuation and identification of errors or discrepancies.
  • Practice attention to detail in your work by thoroughly reviewing appraisal reports and verifying information.
  • Enhance your communication and interpersonal skills to effectively collaborate with colleagues, clients, and other professionals involved in the appraisal process.
  • Stay updated on market trends and industry developments to ensure the accuracy and relevance of appraisal reports.
  • Utilize appraisal software and other IT tools to streamline the appraisal process and minimize the risk of errors.
  • Consider taking additional courses or certifications in specialized areas of appraisal, such as real estate or jewelry, to broaden your knowledge and expertise.
  • Prepare examples from your past experience where you have identified and resolved errors in appraisal reports to showcase your abilities during the interview.

What interviewers are evaluating

  • Attention to detail
  • Effective communication
  • Ability to work independently

Related Interview Questions

More questions for Appraiser interviews